This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

NEW YORK BAGELS
FRESHLY BAKED
BY YOU

SHOP NOW

Your New Favorite Breakfast

Get Yours

Best.
Bagels.
Ever.

shop now at

BRING THE BAGEL SHOP HOME

Find us in a freezer near you

  • KETTLE
    BOILED
  • PARTIALLY
    BAKED
  • ENJOYED
    AT HOME

Bagelista’s done the hard work for you.

Our bagels are handmade, kettle boiled in New York water (it matters!) and baked part-way.

Finish in your oven, air fryer, or toaster oven for crispy-on-the-outside, chewy-on-the-inside, rediculoiusly delicious bagel of epic proportions.

Shop Now

BREAK UP WITH YOUR BAGEL SHOP

BREAK UP WITH YOUR BAGEL SHOP

BREAK UP WITH YOUR BAGEL SHOP

What They're Saying

Warm Bagels! First time I’ve ever had a warm and crunchy bagel! It’s a game changer for me!

Laura K

These Bagels Remind me of my childhood in New York

Anthony F

Tasty AF!
You can't beat the taste of a freshly-baked bagel. I'm definitely ordering more

Jeffery S

Tasty AF!
You can't beat the taste of a freshly-baked bagel. I'm definitely ordering more

Jeffery S

Warm Bagels! First time I’ve ever had a warm and crunchy bagel! It’s a game changer for me!

Laura K

These Bagels Remind me of my childhood in New York

Anthony F

FEATURED IN

WE START IT.
YOU BRING IT HOME.

  • FAMILY
    RECIPE

  • HANDMADE IN
    NEW YORK

  • 24 HOUR
    PROOF

  • KETTLE
    BOILED

  • PARTIALLY
    BAKED

OUR DIFFERENCE

Raising Bagel Standards,
Everywhere.

We’re a husband and wife team on a mission to bring the authentic New York bagel shop experience to your home.

Meet Us

@bagelistabagels

Cart

No more products available for purchase

Your cart is currently empty.